Understanding Offset Transactions: Why Payers Reduce Your Payments

Written By Enrique Gomez

Offsets are one of the most frustrating realities in medical billing. Just when you’re expecting a clean payment, you notice the deposit is short—sometimes by a few dollars, sometimes by a few thousand. The cause? An offset transaction. And while offsets are technically legal and often allowed in payer contracts, they’re rarely communicated in a clear or timely way, leaving providers and billers scrambling to understand the missing money.

What Is an Offset Transaction?

An offset occurs when a payer takes money from a current payment to recover a previous financial adjustment. Instead of issuing a new request or sending a bill, they simply subtract what they believe they’re owed from the next claim payment.

Offsets can occur for several reasons:

  • Overpayments on past claims

  • Retroactive adjustments, such as eligibility changes or corrected coding

  • Internal payer reconciliation, including system corrections or auditing errors

  • Duplicate payments discovered months after the fact

  • Coordination of benefits adjustments

To the provider, it appears as a reduced payment—often without an obvious explanation unless you comb through the EOB/ERA line-by-line.

Why Offsets Cause Problems for Practices

Offsets may be normal in payer operations, but they cause major headaches for billing teams and practice managers.

1. Sudden Short Payments

A claim that should pay $2,500 might deposit as $1,200. Without proper context, it creates unnecessary concern and confusion—especially when multiple claims hit the same deposit.

2. Variances in Accounting Reports

When your payment doesn’t match the posted amount, it throws off:

  • Monthly reconciliation

  • Provider-specific revenue reports

  • Year-over-year comparisons

  • Cash flow projections

This can create a ripple effect across financial dashboards, RVU reports, and management summaries.

3. Poor Communication From Payers

Most offsets are buried inside:

  • Adjustment codes

  • Remark codes

  • Footnotes deep within the remit

Rarely will a payer notify the practice ahead of time. Instead, it becomes your job to investigate why money is missing.

Are Offsets Legal?

Yes—offsets are legal, and most payer contracts include language allowing them to recoup money without seeking your permission. Medicare, Medicaid, and commercial payers all use offsets as standard practice.

However, that doesn’t mean every offset is correct. Errors in payer calculations, duplicate recoveries, or outdated overpayment requests can all trigger inappropriate take-backs.

How to Stay Ahead of Offset Activity

Managing offsets is all about attentive payment review and clean reporting systems. Here’s how to stay in control:

1. Review ERAs and EOBs Carefully

Offsets usually show up as:

  • Code CO-94 (overpayment recovery)

  • Deduction codes

  • Negative payment lines

  • Take-back descriptions

Always verify whether the recovered amount is valid.

2. Track Offsets in Monthly Reporting

For accurate accounting, track:

  • Expected payment

  • Actual payment

  • Offset amount

  • Adjustment reason

  • Claim or date of service affected

This gives you transparency across months and helps identify repeat payer behaviors.

3. Reconcile Offsets to the Correct Claim

Never let offsets sit unreconciled. Match every recovered amount to:

  • The original claim

  • The date of service

  • The original payment amount

This creates a clean audit trail.

4. Appeal When Offsets Are Incorrect

If the payer recovers funds in error:

  • Submit a corrected claim

  • File a formal appeal

  • Request an audit reconsideration

  • Provide evidence (EOBs, medical records, correspondence)

It’s absolutely acceptable—and often necessary—to challenge a payer when the recovery is not justified.

Why Understanding Offsets Matters

Offsets may seem like small nuisances, but they impact big-picture financial health. When left unmanaged, they can:

  • Distort your cash flow

  • Skew provider compensation

  • Hide payer errors

  • Delay accurate monthly and year-end reporting

By understanding how and why offsets happen, practices can safeguard revenue, catch incorrect recoveries early, and maintain clean, transparent accounting.

Final Takeaway

Offsets aren’t going away—but with strong reporting, careful review, and proactive follow-up, your practice can stay ahead of them. The key is understanding how offsets work and building internal processes that catch discrepancies before they snowball into larger problems.

If you ever need help interpreting a specific offset, analyzing a remit, or building a clean offset-tracking template, I’m here to help anytime.

Enrique Gomez
Next

Leveraging CPT Modifiers Correctly to Maximize Reimbursement